°µÍø½ûÇø

Manitoba Court of King's Bench Justice Sarah Inness ruled this week that the complainant believes James abused him as a child but the evidence presented in court was unreliable.

"The issue in this case is more about the reliability of (the complainant's) evidence in identifying James as the perpetrator, as opposed to the credibility of his complaints of sexual assault," Inness said it a written decision Tuesday.

The lawsuit, filed in 2023, also named the St. James Assiniboia School Division, claiming it failed in its duty to protect students.

James admitted to being a substitute teacher in the division in the early '80s but denied teaching at the school where the complainant was enrolled the year of the alleged abuse, the decision said.

The defendants used income tax records, school records and police reports to argue James was not working at the school at the time.

James has numerous convictions of sexual abuse against players while a  coach, and the cases from the mid 1990s to 2015 rocked the hockey world.

The Canadian Hockey Association banned him from coaching for life in 1997. He was granted full parole in 2016.

Inness acknowledged the previous crimes in her decision.

"James is a notorious child sex offender. It is for that reason that care must be taken in fairly assessing (the complainant's) claims, while guarding against the improper use of bad character propensity reasoning," she said.

There was no civil trial, as the defendants argued for a summary judgment. The judge said she was satisfied the suit could be fairly decided  based on the evidence and arguments presented. 

This report by °µÍø½ûÇø was first published Aug. 1, 2025.